An owner running four ships who is weighing a move to ten is usually working from an assumption that the daily cost of running each vessel will come down as the fleet grows. Among Panamax bulk carriers of comparable age and size in 2024, fleets of one to five vessels reported daily operating expenses of 7,362 dollars and fleets of more than twenty reported 7,363 dollars.
The figures come from the Moore Maritime Index, which Moore Greece compiles from the audited financial statements of more than 150 management companies covering about 1,500 vessels, and which groups them by the number of vessels under a single manager. The 2025 edition covers the 2024 financial year.
Read at the level of the whole bulk carrier fleet, scale looks decisive. Managers of more than twenty vessels earned a time charter equivalent of 16,758 dollars a day against 12,625 dollars for managers of one to five. The same comparison on the cost side runs the other way, with the largest managers reporting 7,589 dollars a day against 6,450 dollars for the smallest.
Most of that earnings gap belongs to the ships rather than to the companies. Average vessel capacity in the largest bulk carrier fleets is 114,804 dwt, against 56,391 dwt in fleets of one to five. Managers with more than twenty vessels run a bigger class of ship on average, and size drives both earnings and running cost whoever owns the vessel.
Filtering to a single segment removes that effect. Among Panamax bulk carriers built between 2010 and 2017 with capacity between 60,000 and 120,000 dwt, the four fleet size bands reported 7,362, 6,270, 6,432 and 7,363 dollars a day. The pattern is not a slope. The two middle bands ran roughly a thousand dollars a day cheaper than either end, and the smallest and largest fleets landed within a dollar of each other.
Earnings in the matched group also stop favouring size. Fleets of eleven to twenty vessels reported the highest time charter equivalent at 15,224 dollars a day, and fleets of more than twenty reported the lowest at 12,497 dollars. Measured as earnings against operating cost, the eleven to twenty band returned 2.37 and the largest band 1.70.
Underneath the total, the cost categories behave differently from one another, and only one of them rewards size at all.
Insurance in the matched Panamax group ran 551 dollars a day in the smallest fleets and 443 dollars in the largest, with a dip to 408 dollars in the eleven to twenty band. In tankers of 30,000 to 80,000 dwt built between 2008 and 2015 the decline is steeper and unbroken across all four bands, from 648 dollars a day to 346 dollars. A manager with a larger book writes a better programme, and the saving is real, though at 108 dollars a day in the bulk carrier group and 302 in the tanker group it sits well inside the movement in the total.
Repairs, maintenance and spares moved against the grain. In the Panamax group the smallest fleets reported 1,258 dollars a day and the largest 1,289 dollars, with the two middle bands at 756 and 847 dollars. Crew cost was close to flat across all four bands, running between 3,036 and 3,439 dollars a day. Administration, which carries management fees, was highest in the smallest fleets at 1,481 dollars and second highest in the largest at 1,287 dollars.
The categories an owner might expect to spread across more ships, which are the ones involving people and steel, are the categories that stayed where they were.
Set against 2020, the same Panamax group shows daily operating expenses up 27 percent for fleets of one to five, 13 percent for fleets of six to ten, 15 percent for eleven to twenty and 31 percent for fleets above twenty. Tankers of 40,000 to 60,000 dwt built between 2006 and 2012 show increases of 42 percent for the smallest fleets, 50 percent for six to ten and 18 percent above twenty.
Insurance rose in absolute terms across every band, from 431 dollars a day to 551 in the smallest fleets and from 273 to 443 in the largest, so the gap between them narrowed as the cost itself climbed. Repairs and maintenance in the Panamax group roughly doubled in the smallest fleets, from 595 dollars a day in 2020 to 1,258 dollars in 2024.
The tanker figures carry a confounding factor the bulk carrier figures do not. Vessels in the smallest tanker fleets averaged 15.0 years against 11.5 years in the largest, and age drives maintenance cost on its own. Daily operating expenses in that group do fall as fleet size rises, from 9,238 dollars to 7,812 dollars, and part of that decline is the age difference rather than anything about scale. The Panamax group holds age much closer, between 9.75 and 11.36 years, which is why it carries the weight here.
The data describes management companies rather than owners, so a manager running twenty ships for several principals appears as one large fleet. It covers one financial year in detail and five years of one matched segment, in a period when the categories driving the increases were moving for reasons outside any manager’s control. Moore’s own reading attributes the absence of a clean pattern to human capital, unforeseen events and differing margin targets, none of which the accounts separate.
What the figures establish is narrower than a conclusion about scale. Within this population, over this period, the daily cost of running a bulk carrier of a given type, size and age did not fall as the fleet around it grew, and the earnings advantage visible in the headline numbers followed the ships rather than the fleet count. Whether a particular company would find savings in growth is a question about that company, and these accounts do not answer it.